2016 has been an year of a lot of important judicial decisions. We have tried to pick some of them and list them down for you. 


1. SC paved way for single entrance exam for medical courses

The Supreme Court cleared the decks for holding a single common entrance for admission to all medical and dental courses in the country. With this order, AIPMT will be christened as National Eligibility cum Entrance Exam (NEET) but with a national mandate. The order would imply that all government colleges, deemed universities and private medical colleges would be covered under NEET and those examinations which have already taken place or slated to be conducted separately stand nullified.

2. Banning entry of women of particular age does not come under right to manage religious affair
The Supreme Court in a judgment said that gender equality is a constitutional message and Sabarimala temple management cannot say that banning entry of women of a particular age group comes under their right to manage religious affairs. The bench said the customary practice of banning entry of women between the age group of 10 to 50 years in the Sabarimala temple in Kerala would be examined under the provisions of constitution only.

3. Man can nominate his married daughter to own his property depriving his wife and only son
In a landmark judgment, the Supreme Court has ruled that a man is legally entitled to nominate his married daughter to own his cooperative society flat after his death, depriving his wife and only son.

3.“Better To Dance Than To Beg” Supreme court on dance bars

The Supreme court has ruled that it is better to dance than beg on the streets, as a petition challenged dance bars in Mumbai on grounds that they are "obscene". The court stated: “It is better to dance than to go to streets for begging or earning livelihood through unacceptable means. This is 2016. Dancing is an established profession. But if it becomes obscene, then it does not have legal sanctity.”

4. All tobacco companies to implement the rule mandating 85% pictorial warning

The Supreme Court directed all tobacco companies to implement the rule mandating 85% pictorial warnings on packets of tobacco products. A notification by the health ministry on 24 September 2015 for implementation of the Cigarettes and other Tobacco Products (Packaging and Labeling) Amendment Rules, 2014 came into force on 1 April. It prescribed larger pictorial petitions, covering 85% of the size of the packets of tobacco products, including cigarettes and beedis.

5. Gay, Lesbians and bisexuals not trangsgender

It has been over two years after recognising transgender people as a “third gender” in a historical judgment to ensure them a dignified life. The Supreme Court further clarified to the Centre that its verdict did not include lesbians, gays and bisexual persons under the category of ‘transgenders’. The Centre has still not implemented the 2014 judgment, which directs the government to treat transgender people or eunuchs as a socially and educationally backward class. The court had directed the government to provide them with incentives and benefits in education and jobs in order to help them gain dignity, ability to fight for their constitutional rights and get accepted into mainstream society.

6. Decree granted by church court invalid

The Supreme Court has held divorce decrees granted by ecclesiastical tribunals, popularly known among Christians as church courts, had no legal sanctity and anyone remarrying after such a divorce decree would be committing an offence. A petition was filed by Bengaluru-based octogenarian Catholic advocate Clarence Pais, who has sought legal sanctity for divorce decrees granted by church courts. The bench said, “Unless a divorce decree is granted by the competent court, the decrees granted by church court are not valid. Any man who remarries after divorce decree granted by church court will be committing an offence.”

7. Woman can invoke Domestic Violence Act against husband’s mother, sister

The Bombay High court in a landmark order, has ruled a woman can invoke criminal provisions of the Domestic Violence Act against female relatives of her husband. Hearing a plea filed by Mumbai resident Sachin Patil and his family, challenging the case filed by his estranged wife, especially against his mother and sister, the court said the special law to tackle domestic violence can't be restricted only to the husband's male relatives.


8. Women have the right to enter the inner sanctum of Haji Ali dargah

The HC bench ruled on a public interest litigation which urged lifting restriction on women inside the inner sanctum which houses the mazaar or tomb of the saint. The ban was imposed somewhere between March and June 2012 by the Haji Ali Dargah Trust. The bench held that it is in contravention of Articles 14 (Right to Life), 15 (Prohibition of discrimination) and 25 (Right to practice religion) of the Constitution of India. It directed the status quo ante to be restored and women be allowed entry on par with men.

9. The use of reproduced copyrighted books by student was a “reasonable educational need” and should not be treated as infringement

The Delhi high court dismissed suits by three international publishers against the sale of photocopied books and pages in Delhi University, a landmark verdict likely to have a wide-reaching impact on copyright laws in India. It is held that the use of reproduced copyrighted books by student was a “reasonable educational needs” and should not be treated as infringement. Under the copyright Act, 1957, there are exemptions on “fair use” of work including educational propose from the purview of infringement.

10. Voters have a fundamental right to know the academic qualification of a candidate

In its recent judgment, it has been held by supreme court that Voters have a fundamental right to know the academic qualification of a candidate and any false declaration on this count can warrant rejection of nomination papers. The bench said, “Every voter has a fundamental right to know about the educational qualification of a candidate. It is also clear from the provisions of the Act, Rules and Form 26 that there is a duty cast on the candidates to give correct information about their educational qualifications.”

11. Allegations of sexual perversity amounts to mental cruelty 

Delhi High Court in its judgment said that raising questions of sexual perversity against a husband amounts to mental cruelty and justifies the grant of divorce. The bench said the wife had damaged the very basic fabric of marital bond beyond repair and maligned the “pious relationship” between a father and a daughter. It sounds paradoxical that wife was not letting the husband to have physical contact but the husband was blamed for keeping condoms accessible to their eight years old daughter and also for waking up the daughter in the midnight to witness their sexual activity.

12. National Anthem must be played before movies in theaters

The Supreme Court  ordered that “all the cinema halls in India shall play the national anthem before the feature film starts and all present in the hall are obliged to stand up to show respect to the national anthem” as a part of their “sacred obligation”. Discarding notions of “any different notion or the perception of individual rights”, the bench added that the movie screen shall have the image of the national flag when the anthem is being played and that doors of the halls will remain shut during the anthem so that no disturbance is caused.

13. Triple talaq unconstitutional, it violates rights of Muslim women

The Allahabad high court said that the Islamic practice of divorcing a woman by saying the word ‘talaq’ three successive times is unconstitutional and called a violation of the rights of Muslim women. "Triple talaq is unconstitutional; it violates the rights of Muslim women. No Personal Law Board is above the Constitution," said the Allahabad high court in its order.  It was stated that triple talaq can't be given arbitrarily and personal Law cannot be above the Constitutional law.

14. Child born out of rape entitled to compensation: Delhi High Court

The Delhi High court has ruled that a child born out of rape is entitled to compensation, independent of any such relief granted to the mother. The verdict to this effect, in which a man has been sent to jail for his entire “natural life” for raping his minor step-daughter, was delivered after the court, noted that there was no such provision under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act or under the Delhi government’s victim compensation scheme. It was stated that a child born out of rape, either of a minor or a woman who is an adult, “is clearly a victim of the act of the offender and entitled to compensation independent of the amount of compensation paid to his/her mother.”


Did we make a mistake or miss out any? Please tell us in the comments below or write to us at [email protected]



Written By,

Vidushi