Whether its “Challenge what's possible”, “Because you’re worth it” or “Bringing the best to everyone we touch” or any other commercial’s tagline. We all have heard these taglines of famous products and of more famous celebs endorsing them. While in that process they claim about the authenticity and effectiveness of that product with great confidence. But to what extent should one rely on them.
Some Recent cases:
1) In April 2016, India's limited-overs skipper Mahendra Singh Dhoni was forced to step down as the brand ambassador of real estate firm Amrapali after homebuyers trolled him on Twitter about the delay in completion of the housing project.
2) In April 2002 Genelia D’Souza was summoned by the Andhra Pradesh High Court to explain her version in and role as brand ambassador in a real estate project called ‘Anjaniputra’ located close to Hyderabad Deccan that seems to have gone bust.
3)In April 2015, a court notice was issued against celebrities like Amitabh Bachchan and Madhuri Dixit seeking an explanation from them regarding the promotion of Maggie Noodles. Apart from Maggi, the consumption of many soft drinks such as Pepsi and Coke are also under scrutiny and analysis. Celebrities such as Mahendra Singh Dhoni, ViratKohli have been promoting these products and may be next in line to end up in controversy.
What is the current scenario?
Section 24 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 puts restrictions on misleading advertisements. It states, that “no person” shall be allowed to engage in misleading representation concerning the “standard, quality, quantity or grade-composition” and “need for, or the usefulness” of a food product. (S)he should not make any statement which “gives to the public any guarantee of the efficacy [of the product] that is not based on an adequate or scientific justification thereof.” Section 53 of the Act describes the penalty for such false advertisements which can extend to ten lakh rupees. This penalty applies to “any person” and hence should ideally include the celebrities; however there is no case law to support this proposition. Currently, there is no law which specifically deals with responsibility of celebrities endorsing products. But public figures do have an ethical obligation towards those who follow them and this necessitates a framework that guides them to take responsibility for their public image, which includes the products they endorse.
Scenario in other nations
In the USA, the Federal Trade Commission Guidelines prohibit deceptive and misleading endorsements by celebrities and make celebrities liable for the same. The endorsers are required to reflect their “honest opinions, findings, beliefs, or experience” in the advertisements.Korea on the other hand has an Advertising Self-regulation Institution which issues guidelines with respect to endorsements and reviews the endorsed advertisements making false advertisements a rarity. Among our neighbors, China makes the endorsers jointly liable with the service provider for the harm caused by the product.
What has been proposed in India?
Union minister Ram Vilas Paswan has cracked the whip on endorsements, saying that the celebrities misleading endorsement can bring them under the ambit of consumer protection act. Till now the ambassadors of the products never came under the ambit of the act but if the proposed amendment becomes a law, it will be happening for the very first time.
The Confederation of All India Traders (CAIT) had demanded the inclusion of brand ambassadors under the ambit of the act, as they felt it based on who was the brand ambassador that many consumers make their choice.
Many a times, customers who buy the products because of their favorite celebrity endorsing it are disappointed with the reality of it.
The million dollar question over here is - Is the proposed legal scenario good or bad.
Here are some point in favour and against it.
Points in favour
• Customers buy products because their favorite celebrities endorse for it and declare its effectiveness. But many a times the product is not what they promise.
• The main reason celebrities endorse various products is due to huge money they make out of it. Therefore, they must be held responsible if customers are cheated and they must pay fine out of the money they earned.
• Now-a-days endorsement has become very competitive among celebrities and to remain ahead of others, celebrities endorse for products without checking its quality.
• False advertisements by celebrities in nothing but exploitation of their fan following and their popularity. They must be held answerable for this.
Points against it
• The product endorsement is part of their professional obligation, making them personally liable for same is questionable.
• Customers now a days are much more aware and prudent enough to make their own good decision.
• There is no direct contact between the ultimate customer and the celebrity endorsing for it. So, the celebrity can’t be held liable as he doesn’t force any personal insistence to buy the product.
• The celebrities are nowhere involved in the manufacturing process. They only endorse the product with terms and conditions applied. Making them liable would be harsh.
Whether celebrities should be held accountable for the product they endorse or not depends on the decision to be taken at monsoon session but there must be some monitoring and legal regulation on the part of celebrities before signing any advertising contract.
Share your views in the comments belows or write to us at [email protected]
Care a Share?