Recently, a Muslim woman, who has been a victim of the 'triple talaq' system, has moved the Supreme Court to nullify the prevailing divorce practice. A woman hailing from Jaipur moved the apex court after receiving a divorce letter through speed post. Before coming to the incident, let us know a little about triple talaq system. In Muslim law, Talaq means release from a marriage tie, immediately or eventually. In a restricted sense it means separation effected by the use of certain appropriate words by the husband and in a wide sense it means all separations for causes originating from the husband. It is also generic name for all kinds of divorce but it is particularly applied to the repudiation by or on behalf of husband. It requires three pronouncements made during a single tuhr in one sentence or in three sentence. The practice of triple Talaq has been banned by law in 21 nations, including Pakistan, Iraq, Iran, Indonesia, and Bangladesh. But India still permits it. In all such countries arbitration councils and judicial interventions have been introduced to promote reconciliation.

Recent Instances

Talking about the recent incident where a Muslim woman, victim of the 'triple talaq' system, has moved the Supreme Court to nullify the prevailing divorce practice. 25-yr old Afreen Rehman hailing from Jaipur moved the apex court after receiving a divorce letter through speed post. She got married in 2014 through a matrimonial portal, but after 2-3 months, her in-laws started demanding dowry. Also they, physically and mentally harassed her. Petitioner has challenged the constitutionality of Section 2 of the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937 in so far as it seeks to recognize and validate polygamy, triple talaq and nikahhalala.

The provisions says- “Notwithstanding any custom or usage to the contrary, in all questions (save questions relating to agricultural land) regarding intestate succession, special property of females, including personal property inherited or obtained under contract or gift or any other provision of Personal Law, marriage, dissolution of marriage, including talaq, ila, zihar, lian, khula and mubaraat, maintenance, dower, guardianship, gifts, trusts and trust properties, and wakfs (other than charities and charitable institutions and charitable and religious endowments) the rule of decision in cases where the parties are Muslims shall be the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat).”

Earlier this year, another 35-year-old lady moved SC seeking a ban on instantaneous triple talaq. She thus becomes the first Muslim woman to challenge a personal law practice, citing her fundamental rights.

The Bharatiya Muslim MahilaAndolan (BMMA) had written to the National Commission for Women (NCW) and sought its support to make the practice that "destroys the life of women" as illegal.Supporting the Bharatiya Muslim MahilaAndolan’s move to demand a ban on triple talaq and dubbing it as ‘misinterpretation of ‘ayats’ (verses), Uttar Pradesh’s first woman qaziHina Zaheer Naqvi on Wednesday urged Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government to intervene into the matter and demanded an immediate ban on the practice.

Justice MarkandeyKatju, the former Chairman of Press Council of India reacted to the news and tweeted, “Where are all the mullahs? Are they not going to do anything against these heretics?”  The former Supreme Court judge claimed that the Sharia law has kept the Muslims backward and that civil code is a must.  He said, “I am strongly against oral talaq and burqa among Muslims, and I support the demand of a uniform civil code.”

While on the other side, AIMPLB has submitted that the issue of Muslim Personal Law is cultural issue, and it is inextricably interwoven with Islam. It has argued that it is the issue of freedom of conscience, guaranteed under Article 25 and 26 read with Article 29 of the Constitution. The AIMPLB has also submitted that the Part III of the Constitution does not touch upon the personal laws of the parties, and therefore, the Supreme Court cannot examine the question of constitutional validity of the practices of marriage, divorce and maintenance in Muslim personal law.

It is high time that government should make it clear that either the Muslim Personal Law Board fall in line with modern secularlaw when it comes to the rights of women, or it should just perish. The board can't be let to carry on with its patriarchal and whimsical ways in the name of securing the sharia or Islamic law.In any case, the interpretation and implementation of the practices such as triple talaq go against the sharia itself. The Islamic way of divorce is an elaborate procedure, which includes a mandatory period of arbitration. The utterance of talaq, talaq, talaq thrice at a go is plain un-Islamic. So the Muslim Personal board defends an un-Islamic practice in the name of sharia.

Some Sunni clerics who recognize the practice of triple talaq point to the practice being sanctioned during the reign of the second Caliph Omar. Caliph Omar pronounced triple talaq as final in a few cases where women wanted to walk out of bad marriages desperately and their husbands were delaying the divorce by misusing the long-drawn procedure prescribed in the law. But what we have today is the twisted and turned version of Islamic law.

A high-level committee set up by the Central government to review the status of women in India has reportedly recommended a ban on the practice of oral, unilateral and triple talaq (divorce) and polygamy. 

But the reality is different,Talaq-ul-biddat distorts the fundamental right against any form of discrimination enshrined in Article 15 of the Indian Constitution. From normal format of divorce, Talaq-ul-biddatimpair the essence of Article 21, the right to life and personal liberty. In addition to that various DPSPs under article 38, 39, 44 are grossly led down as Indian Muslim women fell prey to such unjust practices.

Judicial Dynamics

1. A.S.Parveen Akhtar v. Union of India

The court held that whatever be the form of Talaq what is necessary is that several attempts for reconciliation should have been made .Further held that the section 2 of the Muslim Personal Law Application Act is valid and hence the form of Talaq recognized by it is valid and not unconstitutional. Thus the petition was dismissed.

2. Dagdu v. RahimbiDagduPathan

The court held that the Quran states that husband could only divorce his wife for reasonable causes; that Talaq even if it is oral must be proved before the court if it is contested by wife by leading evidences.

3. Nagma Bibi v.  State of Orissa.

It was held that triple Talaq and Halala are not prescribed in Quran, the main source of Shariat and Muslim law. These are social evils and not Islamic practices and only continue to be propagated because of the ignorance of community leaders as well as the community as a whole.

A 2015 survey of about 5,000 women across 10 states by the Bharatiya Muslim MahilaAndolan (BMMA) found that over 90% wanted an end to polygamy and triple talaq. Of the 525 divorced women surveyed, 78% had been given triple talaq; 76 of these women had to consummate a second marriage so that they could go back to their former husbands. 

In India we have arrived at this commonsense that women in marriage have less rights then men. Article 25 and 26 of are equally meant for men and women, whatever be the denomination. Triple Talaq is Against the Progressive spirit of Quran. Itsymbolizes the subordination, subjugation and suppression of human rights of women. The practice of triple Talaq is grossly injurious to the human rights of the Muslim women. This form of Talaq is infested with the malady of inequality which goes against equality which is enshrined in Article 14 of the Indian Constitution. We have moved away from the clutches of orthodoxy and fanaticism, this era is an era of empowerment, literacy and freedom, then why not give women her due. These recent petitions filed in SC must be seen as great opportunity to usher in a much-needed reform.